Advantages of Inland Barge Transportation
(Much of the material presented here is based on the US Department of Transportation, Maritime Administration brochure, “Environmental Advantages of Inland Barge Transportation.”)
Inland barges carry approximately 15 percent of the nation’s freight at the lowest unit cost while offering an environmentally sound alternative to truck and rail transportation.
Shipping by barge
…is more energy efficient.
The measure of energy efficiency in transportation is the amount of energy expended to move a certain weight of load over a given distance, expressed as BTUs required to move one ton one mile (a ton-mile). Water transport expends 433 BTU per ton-mile versus 696 for rail. It is much more efficient to move cargo through water than over land. Supporting this conclusion are the statistical data reflecting the relative distance each mode of transportation can carry one ton of cargo for every gallon of fuel burned.
Key to this efficiency is the ability of barges to carry large loads of bulk materials up to five times their own weight. The cargo capacity of a barge is 15 times that of one rail car and 60 times greater that one semi-trailer truck.
To move the same amount of cargo transported by a standard tow (15 barges) would require a freight train 2.75 miles long or a line of 870 trucks stretching almost 35 miles. On the lower Mississippi, one 10,000 horsepower towboat can push 40 barges, the equivalent of 600 railcars or more than 2200 trucks. If the cargo moved on the inland waterways systems each year had to be moved by rail, it would take 6.3 million cars, or on the road, 25.2 million trucks. Think about the additional traffic and associated air pollution such congestion would bring to our already crowded land systems.
Any proposal to shift the transportation of customary barge commodities to either rail or truck would be inconsistent with the nation’s energy conservation efforts, much less be economically unsound. The costs of such a move in environmental effects must be factored into any evaluation of such a move.
…serves to dampen rates of competitive modes of transportation.
Where barge transportation is available, rates of either truck or rail, particularly rail, tend to be lower.
The corollary is that where barge transportation is not available, rail rates tend to be higher. Shippers are aware of this economic reality as they constantly compare transportation costs in an attempt to reduce operating expenses. Lower costs to the shipper translates into lower costs for the consumer.
An important measure of environmental responsibility is the safety of the public. Statistics show that barge transportation has fewer accidents, fatalities, and injuries than truck or rail in every measure. The following table is extracted from “Inland Waterways as Vital National Infrastructure: Refuting ‘Corporate Welfare’ Attacks,” page 25, by Dr. C. Jake Haulk of the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy, published in 1998.
Per billion ton-miles
* Barge data from National Transportation Statistics Annual Report 1993, pp 32-33
** Truck and rail data from US Statistical Abstract 1993, pp 610, 621, 630. Truck deaths includes only truck occupants. Other victims not counted.
Shallow draft barges operate primarily in areas away from the general population, thus are less exposed to urban areas than truck or rail. The inland waterway system has fewer crossing junctures, minimizing the potential of collision between tows or vehicles carrying people. As a result, the number and impact of waterway incidents are low when compared to truck or rail.
Truck and rail spills occur more often than barge spills. Design features of barges, such as double-hulls and navigational aids, help reduce the frequency of accidents. All new inland tank barges carrying liquid cargoes now have an inner and outer hull. The United States Coast Guard regulates the design and construction of these vessels and equipment as well as qualifications of the personnel manning them. The Coast Guard inspects the vessels annually to ensure compliance.
…causes little congestion
Congestion on our highways is a major safety and environmental headache. Accidents, increased energy consumption, damage to the environment, increased commuting time, increased driver tension, all have a major impact on our daily lives. In contrast, water transport seldom causes congestion problems that represent a hazard to the public. In truth, the inland waterways system is under utilized.
…produces little noise or air pollution
Some of the most pervasive and intrusive sources of noise and air pollution are transportation systems. The noise of road traffic, particularly trucks, can be almost debilitating. Compare the decibels of a passing truck with that of a barge sliding silently through the water, and the difference is overwhelming. Towboats generally operate away from shore with the sound of their engines muffled below the water line.
Pollutants expelled into the air by the tremendous number of trucks on the road are a major hazard to the environment. Road traffic is by far the greatest source of those pollutants.
EPA, Emission Control Lab
|Mode||Hydrocarbons||Carbon Monoxide||Nitrogen Oxide|
(Extracted from “Inland Waterways as Vital National Infrastructure: Refuting “Corporate Welfare” Attacks” by Dr. C. Jake Haulk, Allegheny Institute for Public Policy, p. 24.)
In contrast, barges cause far less air pollution than trucks, and less, or comparable amounts, than rail. Exhaust emissions from barges cumulatively produce fewer emissions per ton-mile of freight carried than either rail or truck. Waterway operations are generally away from population centers so the pollutants barges emit are less intrusive than the other modes of transportation.
…has relatively small effects on land and community
Barges move along isolated waterways generally adhering to natural river channels. Thus, they require minimal modification to the land for support, unlike road or rail, and so generally are less likely to compete with non-transportation uses for that land. Highways and railroad corridors can command large land areas, whereas barges require only some connections and waterside terminals. Barges do not impose unwelcome traffic patterns or congestion upon the community as do trains or trucks. Neither does the barge disturb to any great degree the serenity of a community as tows are less frequent than rail or truck because of greater carrying capacities.
…produces multiple benefits
A navigation waterway also provides ancillary benefits, such as recreation, flood control, water supply, irrigation, and electrical power production, contributing greatly to the quality of life in all waterside communities.
The waterways industry has long had concerns about developing and maintaining our inland waterways in an environmentally responsible way. The businesses that make up the barge and towing industry are dedicated to operating in a way to reduce to the absolute minimum any negative effects on the environment. They also realize that development of those waterways can be compatible with the protection of the ecological health of the river basins in which they operate.